Skip to next element

Price Difference Between VS1 and VS2 Diamonds: Understanding the Value Gap

Two diamonds side by side for price comparison
Delve into the clarity scale nuances to discern the price variance between VS1 and VS2 diamonds. While both offer high clarity, VS1 diamonds may command a premium due to fewer and less visible inclusions. Grasp these distinctions to make an informed and value-conscious decision when selecting the perfect diamond for your jewelry.

When considering the purchase of a diamond, clarity is a crucial factor that significantly impacts its value. Diamonds are graded based on their clarity, which refers to the presence of inclusions and blemishes. Two common grades you might encounter in your search are VS1 and VS2, which stand for Very Slightly Included levels one and two, respectively. Understanding the distinctions between these clarity grades is essential, as they directly influence the price you'll pay.

The price difference between VS1 and VS2 diamonds can be subtle but meaningful, depending on several attributes such as size, shape, and overall appeal. VS1 diamonds are a grade higher on the clarity scale than VS2, meaning VS1 stones contain fewer and less detectable inclusions, often commanding a higher price. The premium for a VS1 compared to a VS2 diamond arises from its rarity and higher clarity rating, making it a more desired—but also more expensive—option.  

As you explore options and determine what fits both your preferences and budget, consider the balance between a diamond's clarity and its cost. With a keen eye and the right information, you can make an informed decision on whether the additional expense for a VS1 clarity grade aligns with your desires for that perfect gemstone.

Understanding Diamond Clarity

Diamond clarity is a critical factor in determining a gem's quality and value. It refers to the presence of inclusions and blemishes which can affect a diamond's beauty. As you assess diamond clarity, the grading scale and understanding of common imperfections are essential.

Clarity Scale and Grades

The GIA Diamond Clarity Scale consists of 11 grades, ranging from Flawless (FL) to Included (I1, I2, I3). "Flawless" diamonds have no inclusions or blemishes visible under 10x magnification. The term "Internally Flawless" (IF), indicates no inclusions and only surface blemishes.

Moving down the scale, we encounter Very Slightly Included (VVS1 and VVS2) grades, which contain minute inclusions that are difficult even for skilled graders to see under 10x magnification. Slightly Included (SI1 and SI2) diamonds have noticeable inclusions under magnification, which may or may not be visible to the naked eye. Those with obvious inclusions fall under the Included (I1, I2, I3) category, which often affect transparency and brilliance.

Common Inclusions and Blemishes

Inclusions are internal characteristics such as crystals, feathers, and clouds, whereas blemishes are surface imperfections like scratches and nicks. Types of inclusions vary, but among the most common are:

  • Crystals or Minerals: Tiny crystals of other minerals embedded within the diamond.
  • Feathers: Small cracks that can appear wispy, sometimes affecting durability if located at the surface.
  • Clouds: A cluster of tiny pinpoints that can make a diamond appear hazy or dull if extensive.

The type, size, and location of these imperfections dictate a diamond's placement on the clarity chart, impacting its desirability and price. For example, a VS1 diamond with very minor inclusions will be valued higher than a VS2 diamond where inclusions are more apparent. Remember, each diamond is unique, and its individual inclusions contribute to this uniqueness.

VS1 vs VS2 Clarity Overview

Aspect VS1 Clarity VS2 Clarity
Clarity Grade VS1 (Very Slightly Included 1) VS2 (Very Slightly Included 2)
Inclusions Small, minor inclusions that are challenging to locate under 10x magnification. Slightly larger or more numerous inclusions than VS1, still difficult to detect without magnification.
Nature of Inclusions VS1: Small, isolated inclusions with minimal impact on brilliance. VS2: Slightly larger or more noticeable inclusions, still with minimal impact on brilliance.
Visibility VS1: Inclusions are very difficult to see without magnification. VS2: Inclusions may be more noticeable but still not easily visible to the naked eye.
Impact on Appearance Both grades have minimal impact on the overall appearance and brilliance of the diamond.
Price VS1 diamonds are generally priced higher than VS2 due to their slightly better clarity. VS2 diamonds are slightly more affordable than VS1.

When choosing a diamond, the clarity can significantly affect its value. VS1 and VS2, which stand for Very Slightly Included 1 and 2 respectively, are two grades on the diamond clarity scale that are often compared for their impact on price and appearance.

Characterizing VS1 Clarity

VS1 diamonds have inclusions that are difficult to see under 10x magnification. These flaws are minor and typically cannot be seen with the naked eye, making a VS1 diamond a high-quality choice that balances clarity and value. The VS1 clarity grade indicates that the diamond's inclusions are located in less visible areas or are so small that they require a trained eye to detect, even with magnification.

Characterizing VS2 Clarity

In contrast, diamonds graded as VS2 have inclusions that are only slightly more noticeable under 10x magnification compared to VS1, but are still not visible to the naked eye in most cases. VS2 clarity means the inclusions may be more prominent or located in areas that are more visible when examined closely. These inclusions are still considered minor; however, the price of a VS2 graded diamond may be less than that of a VS1 due to these clarity characteristics.

Close up of a high quality diamond ring

Factors Affecting Diamond Value

When evaluating diamonds, understanding how various factors influence their value is crucial. Characteristics such as clarity, cut, carat weight, and color play integral roles in determining a diamond's worth.

The Impact of Cut on Clarity

A high-quality cut enhances a diamond's brilliance and can make inclusions less visible, possibly making a VS2 (Very Slightly Included 2) diamond appear closer in clarity to a VS1 (Very Slightly Included 1). However, a poor cut can accentuate flaws, diminishing the clarity and value.

Carat Weight and Price

As the carat weight increases, the price of a diamond escalates, often disproportionately. Larger diamonds are rarer and in higher demand, causing exponential price jumps. While size significantly impacts price, a heavier diamond with a lesser clarity grade, such as VS2, might be less valuable than a lighter but higher-clarity VS1 diamond.

Color and Clarity Interaction

Diamond color grades, ranging from D (colorless) to Z (light yellow), directly interact with clarity when determining value. A diamond with a lower color grade but higher clarity, like VS1, may fetch similar prices to a higher color grade but lower clarity, like VS2. This balance between color and clarity is a nuanced aspect of diamond quality and price.

A guy checking the quality of a diamond

Price Analysis

When it comes to purchasing diamonds, understanding the nuances that affect their price is essential. Specifically, you'll notice a variation in cost between diamonds graded VS1 and those graded VS2, which are classifications of clarity.

Evaluating Price Difference

VS1 and VS2 represent clarity grades in diamonds where VS stands for "Very Slightly Included." The main difference lies in the visibility and number of inclusions. VS1 diamonds have inclusions that are typically harder to see under 10x magnification compared to VS2, where inclusions are more apparent.

For instance, you might find a 1 carat round diamond that is G in color, and VS1 in clarity listed on James Allen for approximately $6,000. A similar diamond but with a VS2 clarity grade may cost you about $5,700. This price difference reflects the slight variations in inclusions that are factored in by the market and perceived value.

Market Comparison

The prices between retailers like James Allen and Blue Nile may show some discrepancy due to factors beyond clarity grades, such as inventory, demand, and overhead costs. However, comparing the price difference between VS1 and VS2 diamonds across these platforms can inform your purchasing decision.

  • James Allen: You may find that the retailer lists VS1 diamonds at a premium of around 5% to 20% over VS2 diamonds, contingent on other characteristics such as cut, color, and carat weight.
  • Blue Nile: The pricing strategy might be similar, but occasionally you'll discover differences due to specific sales or available inventory.

The value of a diamond ultimately depends on how much you, as a consumer, are willing to pay. Retailers adjust their prices based on the cost of procurement and their unique pricing algorithms. Your choice between VS1 and VS2 should also consider the price difference in relation to your personal standards for a diamond's visual appeal and your budget.

A branded shop selling diamonds

Purchasing Considerations

When selecting a diamond, whether for an engagement ring or another piece of jewelry, understanding the nuances of diamond quality is crucial for matching your budget with the desired appearance.

Diamond Shape and Clarity

The shape of the diamond significantly influences how inclusions are seen. Some shapes, like the round brilliant, are more forgiving with clarity, and imperfections are less visible. A higher clarity grade, such as VS1 (Very Slightly Included 1), might be preferred in shapes like emerald or asscher, where inclusions are more noticeable due to their broad, open tables.

  • VS1 diamonds often have inclusions that are not visible to the naked eye.
  • VS2 diamonds might contain inclusions that are typically eye-clean, though this can vary based on diamond shape.

Choosing the Right Clarity for Your Budget

Your budget is a key driver in determining diamond clarity. VS1 diamonds are usually more expensive than VS2 diamonds because they have fewer and smaller inclusions. Consider choosing a:

  • VS1 if your budget allows for a premium, and the priority is minimal inclusions.
  • VS2 if you're looking for a diamond that balances clarity and value, potentially allocating more of your budget towards other characteristics like cut or size.

Lab Grown vs Mined Diamond Clarity

Aspect Lab-Grown Diamonds Mined Diamonds
Formation Created in a controlled laboratory environment using advanced technological processes. Naturally formed deep within the Earth's mantle over millions of years.
Inclusions May have fewer inclusions due to controlled growth conditions. Can have a variety of inclusions, depending on the diamond's geological history.
Nature of Inclusions Typically smaller and less varied, may include minimal or no natural inclusions. May have a broader range of inclusions, including minerals, crystals, or other features.
Clarity Grading Often achieves higher clarity grades due to controlled growth and fewer natural inclusions. Clarity grading considers the natural inclusions and blemishes found in mined diamonds.
Price Generally more affordable than mined diamonds, but price can vary based on other factors. Pricing influenced by factors such as rarity, size, and quality of natural diamonds.
Environmental Impact May be considered a more environmentally friendly option due to reduced environmental impact. Mined diamonds have environmental considerations, including mining impact and resource extraction.

When it comes to clarity, lab grown diamonds and mined diamonds can both achieve high clarity grades, including VS1 and VS2, but your choice might influence value perception and cost.

Certifications of Diamonds

Expert Advice and Certification

When you're planning to purchase a diamond, understanding nuances like the price difference between VS1 and VS2 clarity grades is crucial. Expert advice and thorough certification from reputable organizations can guide you in making an informed decision.

Consulting with a Gemologist

Seeking guidance from a certified gemologist is a step you cannot afford to skip. These professionals possess the knowledge to discern between various clarity grades, such as VS1 and VS2, which might seem negligible to the untrained eye but can significantly impact price and quality. A gemologist can provide you with a detailed analysis of a diamond's characteristics, ensuring you understand exactly what you're paying for.

Understanding Diamond Certifications

Obtaining a diamond certification from a respected authority, such as the Gemological Institute of America (GIA), adds an additional layer of confidence in your purchase. A GIA report specifies the diamond's key attributes, including its clarity grade, which directly influences its cost. Ensure that the diamond you're interested in comes with a certification that validates its VS1 or VS2 status, as this certification confirms the gem's quality and authenticity.

High Quality Moissanite Engagement Rings for sale

Advanced Clarity Characteristics

When you're exploring the intricacies of diamond clarity, understanding the nuanced differences between various clarity grades is paramount. Specifically, VS1 and VS2 clarity grades often come with their own set of advanced clarity characteristics which can influence both aesthetics and value.

Rare Clarity Features

In VS1 diamonds, inclusions are minor and can range from tiny crystals to small feathers, which are often invisible to the naked eye. These inclusions are typically located on the diamond's periphery or deep within the stone, making them even less noticeable. Rare clarity features in VS1 stones can include pinpoint crystals or very small clouds that do not detract from the stone's overall sparkle.

Conversely, VS2 diamonds may have a few more or slightly larger inclusions, such as clouds, crystals, or feathers. It's essential for you to know that rare clarity features in VS2 diamonds, while still minute, are often considered more noticeable under 10x magnification compared to those in VS1 diamonds, but they are generally not detectable to the naked eye.

Visual Perception of Inclusions

Your ability to perceive these inclusions with the naked eye largely depends on the type and placement of the clarity characteristics:

  • Needles & Crystals: Thin, elongated inclusions known as needles or small crystals inside the diamond may be practically invisible unless examined closely.
  • Feathers: Small internal fractures are termed feathers. In VS1 diamonds, they are usually inconsequential to the stone's overall integrity and typically do not affect transparency.
  • Clouds: Clusters of tiny inclusions can create hazy areas referred to as clouds. In VS1 graded diamonds, such clouds are minimal and do not impact the sparkle.

The clarity grade between VS1 and VS2 can impact the price due to these small differences in inclusions. Although they require magnification to identify, knowing the nature of the inclusions can help you make an informed purchase decision. Remember, the presence of inclusions like needles, crystals, and clouds in VS2 diamonds can be more pronounced than in VS1, potentially influencing value and appearance under scrutiny.

Frequently Asked Questions

When considering the purchase of a diamond, understanding the clarity grades VS1 and VS2 is crucial as it significantly influences price and appearance.

What are the key factors that determine the price difference in VS1 and VS2 diamond clarity grades?

The price difference between VS1 and VS2 diamonds stems mostly from the size, number, position, nature, and color of inclusions. VS1 diamonds typically have fewer and smaller inclusions compared to VS2, making them less visible and often more valuable.

How does the price of a VS1 clarity diamond compare to a VS2 of the same carat weight?

A VS1 clarity diamond generally commands a higher price than a VS2 diamond of the same carat weight on account of its superior clarity and lesser inclusions, which are deemed more desirable in the diamond market.

In what scenarios should one consider upgrading from VS2 to VS1 clarity?

You should consider upgrading to VS1 if you seek a diamond with fewer inclusions that are less likely to be seen without magnification. Especially in larger diamonds, where inclusions may be more noticeable, moving to a VS1 grade can assure a cleaner appearance.

What is the impact of diamond color on the price of VS2 diamonds compared to VS1?

The impact of diamond color on VS2 and VS1 graded diamonds can be significant since color can either mask or highlight inclusions. A higher color grade in combination with higher clarity can result in a more pronounced price increase due to the enhanced overall quality.

Are the visual differences between VS1 and VS2 clarity grades noticeable to the naked eye?

The visual differences between VS1 and VS2 clarity grades are usually not noticeable to the untrained eye, especially when the diamond is set in jewelry. However, under close inspection or in larger diamonds, the differences may become more apparent.

How does the presence of inclusions affect the valuation of VS1 and VS2 diamonds?

Inclusions can considerably affect the valuation of VS1 and VS2 diamonds, with VS1 stones typically having a higher value since their inclusions are fewer, smaller, and less visible. The type and location of inclusions in VS2 diamonds might reduce their value if they are more prominent or detract from the diamond's brilliance.


Checkout some of our top collections:

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published.